Skip to content
  1. Home
  2. Blog
  3. Gamification in Performance Management: Give Employees a Reason to Improve
Employee Engagement

Gamification in Performance Management: Give Employees a Reason to Improve

Joris Beerda1 May 2023
Caixa regional sales team at a morning stand-up, discussing a shared results dashboard on the wall screen

When a company comes to us for gamification in performance management, the pattern is a system that counts: calls made, visits logged, proposals sent, training modules completed. Employees deliver the count and stop there. Effort peaks before the quarterly deadline and falls away once the target is met. The bonus that once produced extra effort is now treated as part of the pay, and it takes a bigger one to get the same response.

Tighter targets and closer monitoring get you more of the same compliance. The system tells employees what the company wants and gives them no reason to want it too. An employee who complies stops at the count. An employee who wants to improve keeps working on the job after the count is met.

Gamification in performance management means designing goals, feedback and recognition so that getting better at the job is something people want to do. It does not mean putting points, badges and a leaderboard on top of the appraisal. We learn from games because playing one is always voluntary. The moment a game gets boring, people drop it, so successful games have had to optimize their design for human motivation. That is what gamification takes from them.

This is the core of our work on employee engagement, and the Octalysis Framework shows where a performance system loses people: in what the system rewards, in how much choice it leaves people, and in treating everyone with the same job title as the same person. After we redesigned the daily sales work at Navo Orbico, a Procter & Gamble distributor, revenue rose 28.6% against the company’s historical performance, and 99.5% of eligible employees joined an experience nobody was required to use.

Activity targets reward labor

An activity scorecard counts calls, visits, proposals, training modules and one-to-ones. These are measures of labor. They record that someone did the work and say nothing about how well they did it.

I described the same problem in online communities some years ago. A community that rewards members for every like and comment gets a lot of likes and comments and very little worth reading, because people interact to collect the reward. That is labor-driven design. In performance-driven design, contributors are rewarded when their post gets traction with other members, so they take more care over what they post. I make the same case for loyalty programs that pay members a fixed reward per post.

Performance management works the same way. Reward the number of visits alone and you get visits, including the ones that were never worth making. Reward what the visit achieved, such as an account that grew or a customer problem that was solved, and the rep starts caring about how good the visit is.

This changes motivation as well as numbers. A full call log says something about your diligence. A result that depended on your own judgment says something about your ability. You chose how to do it, and the result told you whether you were right. People feel proud of that and want to repeat it.

Counting activity is still useful. An accurate CRM record, a stock check or a finished training module matters long before it shows up in revenue. Work turns into labor when the count is rewarded alone, with nothing that connects it to a result or to anything the employee cares about. At Navo Orbico we rewarded the right sales activities and the sales result side by side, and the activities had consequences a rep could see.

Ratings and bonuses run on pressure

Many targets come down from above as a number with the method attached: this many calls, this script, this sequence. The employee’s part is to execute. When a rating and a bonus are what keep them executing, two Core Drives are doing the work. Fear of a poor rating is Core Drive 8: Loss & Avoidance. A bonus or ranking that only a few can win is Core Drive 6: Scarcity & Impatience.

In Octalysis these are Black Hat Core Drives. They move people through pressure, and they are very good at creating urgency, which is why the quarter-end push works. A performance system needs some of that, because good intentions alone do not get the CRM updated on a Friday afternoon. The weakness is what pressure does to people over time. Someone driven mainly by pressure often comes to feel that they are no longer in control of their own work. They do what is needed to make the pressure stop, and some leave when they get the chance.

The bonus has a second problem. In Actionable Gamification, Yu-kai Chou describes the Overjustification Effect: when people keep doing something for a high extrinsic reward, the reward takes the place of whatever interest they had in the activity itself. The more a rep works for the bonus, the less interest in the work is left, and the more the system depends on that bonus to get the same effort. I would still keep it. Extrinsic rewards give people a reason to start. What keeps them improving has to come from the work.

Empowerment of Creativity & Feedback: choice and fast feedback

What a system like this lacks is agency, and in Octalysis agency is Core Drive 3: Empowerment of Creativity & Feedback. It needs two things. The first is a real choice between different ways of reaching the goal. The second is feedback fast enough to show whether the choice worked. A prescribed method removes the first. Feedback that arrives only at the quarterly review comes too late to supply the second.

Chou has a simple test for meaningful choices. If a hundred players all reach the Win State in the exact same way, the experience has none. A performance system with one script and one sequence fails that test for every employee in it.

Here is the loop when it works. A rep has a store account that stopped growing, and the promotion of the month has not changed that. On her next visit she goes through the shelves with the store manager and proposes a different order pattern for the products that keep selling out. Two weeks later she sees the result for that store: the order went up and fewer products ran out. She tries the same approach at two more stores and changes it where it did not work. She tried something, saw what happened and made it better, and the improvement is hers. Had the result reached her three months later in a review meeting, she would not have known which decision produced it.

New hires and veterans need different things

Most performance systems stay the same however long someone has been in the job. The targets go up and the experience does not change. The Experience Phases of Octalysis show why that costs more the longer a person stays.

Onboarding is where people learn the rules and the tools. For a new hire, a clear and fairly linear path is right. They need to feel that the job is doable and to reach a first real win quickly.

Scaffolding is the regular journey of repeated actions toward a goal. When the targets and the prescribed method stay the same, a rep’s tenth quarter looks like the second. The same holds for a service agent closing tickets or an engineer working through a backlog. Chou notes that Core Drive 3: Empowerment of Creativity & Feedback is more commonly effective in Scaffolding and the Endgame than in the earlier phases, because newcomers shy away from the effort that creative work takes. By Scaffolding people know the job, and repeated work stays interesting when they can keep trying different strategies and seeing different results.

The Endgame is about how you retain your veterans. For a rep who has mastered the usual accounts, another round of the same targets offers little new challenge. What can hold them is room to use what they know: their own approach to the hardest accounts, ideas the company has not tried, and a role in training newer colleagues, which adds Core Drive 5: Social Influence & Relatedness. Designed well, Empowerment of Creativity & Feedback is evergreen. The person’s own creativity keeps the work fresh, so the company does not have to keep adding something new. A veteran with that room sets their own next challenge.

The same job title hides different motivations

A system that offers choice has to know which choices its people want. Marketing answers that with personas. A persona for a field sales rep might read: mid-thirties, eight years with the company, two children, values stability, follows football. That describes how someone lives. It says nothing about what makes them try harder on a Tuesday afternoon.

A Player Type answers that question. It shows how a group of employees is motivated inside the experience, by which Core Drives, and therefore what to design for them. We do not take Player Types from a stock typology. We work them out for each workforce, usually from the two characteristics that most divide how people approach the work.

In a field sales team those characteristics might be experience and whether someone prefers to work alone or with colleagues. An experienced rep who works alone wants hard accounts and her own way of winning them. For a rep like her, we would expect Core Drive 3: Empowerment of Creativity & Feedback to be strongest, with Core Drive 2: Development & Accomplishment close behind, because she also wants to see her skill grow. The research on a real team confirms or corrects that. For her we would design open challenges where the goal is set and the route is hers.

An experienced colleague who likes working with others wants to be the person the team comes to. Core Drive 5: Social Influence & Relatedness may lead for him, together with Core Drive 1: Epic Meaning & Calling, the wish to be useful to more than himself. For him we would design a mentoring role, with recognition when a method he shared works for someone else. A newcomer mostly needs proof that she is getting better. That is Core Drive 2: Development & Accomplishment again, without the appetite for open challenges that comes with experience. For her we would design visible levels of mastery tied to results she can reach in her first months.

All three have one job description and one target, and a single incentive plan treats them as the same person. This does not mean a separate program for each group. It is one experience in which all of them take the same Desired Actions, with a path that fits each dominant Player Type. Player Types also show in which phase a group is likely to lose interest. Someone who likes working with others may do well in Onboarding, surrounded by trainers and other new hires, and fade in Scaffolding when the work becomes solitary. A lifestyle persona has nothing to say about that.

What this looked like at Navo Orbico

Navo Orbico distributes Procter & Gamble brands such as Ariel and Pampers and operates in 19 countries. When the company came to us through our Polish licensee Funtiago, sales had stagnated and turnover in the sales team was rising. Cash bonuses were in place and no longer produced additional effort. The selling got done, while CRM entries and stock checks were often neglected and training programs had low completion rates. Reps in the field had no feedback on their activities and felt disconnected from headquarters and from each other.

We designed an experience called Master of the Endless Sea, which Funtiago developed on top of the CRM the teams already used, so the experience became the daily workflow. It was implemented in Poland first. Each rep became the Captain of a trading ship. The sales territory became the open sea, clients became colonies to trade with, and the team shared a Port City. The full design is in our Navo Orbico case study. Three parts of it matter most for performance management.

Activity and results were rewarded together. Each rep and the city had two meters, health and wealth. Selling products built wealth. Doing the right sales activities built health, and health had consequences. A healthy and wealthy city grew. If the collective sales targets were missed, the city suffered natural disasters and pirate attacks. The more of those activities a rep did, the bigger and faster their ship became and the faster they got feedback from headquarters on their own sales results. A stock check on an ordinary weekday now led somewhere the rep could see.

Reps had full autonomy over which actions and strategy to follow. They upgraded their ships, which stood for their skills, to carry more cargo, which stood for their sales targets, and they chose their own strategy for growth. Choice of strategy and fast feedback are the two things Core Drive 3: Empowerment of Creativity & Feedback needs, and autonomy of this kind is often lacking in sales organizations.

The pressure in the design came with a way back. The threat to the city works through Core Drive 8: Loss & Avoidance, and the targets were group targets with an individual target next to them. A rep who had a weak period could make up for it by helping colleagues with their sales, by taking training or, with enough experience, by giving training. We used the threat of a loss and always left people a straightforward way out of it. For veterans, giving training was also a role that used what they knew.

The social side mattered as much. A space called the Tavern became the place where reps exchanged ideas and best practices and where management shared news. The leaderboard showed each person only the few colleagues just above and below them, which made it less intimidating for people outside the top positions.

Participation was voluntary, and 99.5% of eligible employees joined. Navo Orbico reported revenue up 28.6% against its own historical performance, a 60% improvement in the KPIs for sales input activities such as up-selling and accurate reporting, and a 300% increase in social interaction among the sales staff. The program won Best Gamification Project at the Europe Gamification Awards. These figures come from a redesign of daily sales work, and I would not use them as evidence about appraisal forms or rating scales. What they show is that a sales team with low motivation chose, almost to a person, to take part in an experience built on fast feedback, their own choice of strategy and progress they shared with colleagues.

Where a leaderboard helps and where it hurts

A leaderboard is often the first thing a company adds when it brings gamification into performance management. A ranking of everyone motivates the people who believe they can reach the top and can discourage everyone else. At Navo Orbico we kept the ranking and changed what each person saw. Chou describes the same variation in Actionable Gamification: place the user in the middle of the display, next to the players ranked just above and just below. I go through more options in how to design leaderboards that motivate everyone.

The other option is a goal people reach together. At Caixa Econômica Federal, a Brazilian bank with about 83,000 employees in 4,500 branches, we built the program around one shared national goal, so employees across branches worked toward the same result together. The goal was to raise net income from R$8.6 billion to R$9 billion. Voluntary participation rose from about 10% to 92%, and during the program the bank reported net income of R$12.7 billion, an increase of 48%. Whether you use a ranking, a shared goal or both depends on how your people experience competition and collaboration, and that differs from one organization to the next.

What we change in a performance system

Since 2013 we have done this design work with more than 175 companies, and it always starts in the same place: the business result you need and the Desired Actions that produce it. Those go into the Octalysis Strategy Dashboard, together with the Player Types in your workforce and the feedback and rewards people get today.

Then we analyze what your current system does to each Player Type in each phase. We look at whether ratings move people mainly through Core Drive 8: Loss & Avoidance, whether the bonus works on them through Core Drive 6: Scarcity & Impatience, and where choice and feedback are missing. From there we design what is needed: rewards for what the work achieves next to the activities that matter, real choices of approach with feedback fast enough to learn from, and roles that give experienced people a reason to stay and to teach. The result does not have to look like a game. In a bank or an insurer the same design can sit inside the tools people already use.

If you have to keep raising the incentive to get the same response, the next bonus buys the same compliance at a higher price, and your employees still have no reason of their own to get better at the work. Contact us and tell us the one behavior you have to keep pushing for.

Gamification in performance management: frequently asked questions

What is gamification in performance management?

Gamification in performance management means designing goals, feedback and recognition so that getting better at the job is something employees want to do. It applies what successful games have learned about human motivation to daily work. It does not mean putting points, badges and a leaderboard on top of the appraisal.

Does gamification replace performance reviews?

No. The review can stay. What changes is what happens between reviews: goals that leave employees a real choice of approach, feedback that arrives fast enough to learn from, and recognition for what the work achieved. Feedback that arrives only at the quarterly review comes too late for Core Drive 3: Empowerment of Creativity & Feedback. Our article on motivation in the workplace looks at how people are praised and appraised more broadly.

Should a performance system reward activity or results?

Both. Rewarding an activity count alone is a labor-driven reward: you get the count, including the visits that were never worth making. A performance-driven reward pays for what the work achieved. At Navo Orbico, The Octalysis Group rewarded sales results and the right sales activities side by side, and the activities had consequences a rep could see, such as faster feedback on their own sales results.

Do leaderboards improve employee performance?

A ranking of everyone motivates the people who believe they can reach the top and can discourage everyone else. At Navo Orbico, each rep saw only the few colleagues just above and below them. At Caixa Econômica Federal, the program was built around one shared national goal that employees across branches worked toward together.

What results has gamification in performance management produced?

For Navo Orbico, a Procter & Gamble distributor, The Octalysis Group redesigned the daily sales work. Navo Orbico reported revenue up 28.6% against its own historical performance, a 60% improvement in the KPIs for sales input activities and a 300% increase in social interaction among the sales staff. Participation was voluntary, and 99.5% of eligible employees joined. The program won Best Gamification Project at the Europe Gamification Awards. At Caixa Econômica Federal, voluntary participation rose from about 10% to 92%, and during the program the bank reported net income of R$12.7 billion, up from R$8.6 billion, an increase of 48%. These are results from our work on employee engagement.

Can AI improve performance management?

AI can predict who is likely to leave, automate recognition and surface sentiment data. Prediction and personalization alone do not give employees a reason to improve. The motivation has to be designed first. Then AI can personalize inside that design, for example which challenge someone sees and when feedback reaches them. We cover this in why AI employee engagement fails without motivation and in our hub on AI user engagement.

Already have a project in mind? Let’s work together!

Our team will listen to your engagement challenges and decide if we are the best match.

Get in touch

Case studies

Measured results from our client work

See all 14 case studies

Hospitality

Hospitality Conversion Gamification

The Octalysis Group created a new industry standard for hospitality and travel booking platforms.

33.4%Increase in gross bookings

Loyalty

Gamified Loyalty Program

Gamified loyalty experience with personalized missions and rewards, leading to record-breaking engagement and conversions.

+153%Increase in credit card acquisitions

Fast-moving Consumer Goods

Sales Force Engagement

Gamified sales platform transforming reps into virtual traders, boosting engagement and performance across 19 countries. Best Gamification Award.

+28.6%Increase in sales revenue